The "I was thirsty" mission in Thunder Bay exemplifies profound compassion. Filling the immediate, life-threatening gap of water insecurity for the city’s vulnerable population. Yet, as with any large-scale distribution of bottled products, a critical question remains: what happens to the plastic when the water is gone? The next challenge for this vital program is how to mitigate plastic water bottle waste.

By distributing over 14,000 bottles since its launch, "I was thirsty" has saved lives and affirmed human dignity. To align this vital humanitarian work with environmental responsibility, the next step is to integrate a robust, dignity-focused waste mitigation plan.

Here are three practical strategies for the 'I was thirsty' initiative to mitigate the plastic bottle waste. Turning potential litter into an asset for the community and the environment.


 

1. Implement a Dignity-Focused Bottle-Back Incentive

 

The single most effective tool for encouraging the return of beverage containers in Canada is the Deposit-Return Scheme (DRS). The scheme places a refundable cash value on the bottle. This existing economic incentive can be harnessed and streamlined to directly benefit the recipients.


 

2. Strategic Placement of Dedicated Collection Bins

 

While mobile collection is ideal for encampments, establishing permanent, user-friendly collection infrastructure at key partner locations would capture a significant portion of the bottles.

 

Why Jesus said I AM THIRSTY on the cross | John 19:28

 


 

3. The "Closed Loop" Partnership

 

The final step is to leverage the goodwill and media visibility of the project. Ensure secure partnership that gives the plastic a second life.

By adopting this three-pronged approach—offering a financial incentive, establishing clear collection infrastructure, and building strategic recycling partnerships—"I was thirsty" can continue its life-saving work, mitigate plastic water bottle waste, and set a new standard for environmentally and socially responsible street outreach in Thunder Bay.

Good Will, Good Waste Management...

The Circularity Paradox: Is the Second-Hand Clothing Boom Fueling, Not Fighting, Fast Fashion?

The rise of the second-hand clothing market has long been championed as a beacon of hope in the fight against fast fashion's environmental and ethical toll. From charity shops to trendy online consignment platforms, buying "preloved" garments is widely promoted as a sustainable choice, a direct antidote to the relentless cycle of new production and waste. Yet, a recent critical study, "From Preloved to Reloved: How Second-Hand Clothing Companies Facilitate the Transaction of Used Garments" by Turunen and Gossen (2024), published in the Journal of Sustainability Research, issues a stark warning: the very business models designed to promote reuse may inadvertently be accelerating consumption, creating a "circular economy rebound" effect that undermines true sustainability.

This research, focusing on the Finnish market, peels back the glossy veneer of sustainable marketing to reveal a fundamental tension: the inherent conflict between profit-driven transaction and genuine sufficiency. It's a paradox that demands urgent attention, especially as the Global North's textile waste crisis increasingly becomes the Global South's problem, manifesting as "waste colonialism."

 

The Core Contradiction: Transaction vs. Sufficiency

 

Turunen and Gossen's study dives deep into the operational and marketing strategies of 20 Finnish second-hand clothing companies. Their central, unsettling finding is that these businesses, despite their environmental mission, are predominantly structured around prioritizing transactions and profitability over sufficiency-oriented practices.

Sufficiency, in the context of sustainability, refers to a reduction in overall consumption; it's about making things last, repairing, reusing, and ultimately buying less. However, the authors argue that the high operational costs associated with sorting, cleaning, marketing, and selling second-hand items—which is often a labor-intensive process—compel these companies to prioritize high-volume sales. To survive and thrive, they must encourage frequent purchasing, often mirroring the very tactics employed by fast fashion retailers.

This creates a self-defeating loop. The more efficiently a second-hand company sells, the more it encourages people to buy. If consumers are merely replacing new purchases with second-hand ones, that's a win. But if the "thrill of the find" in a second-hand store leads to additional purchases, beyond what's truly needed, then the net environmental benefit diminishes, and the potential for a "rebound effect" becomes very real. The sustainability argument hinges entirely on whether buying second-hand displaces new purchases, or merely supplements them.

 

Marketing Tactics: Unmasking the "Circular Economy Rebound"

 

The research meticulously details how specific marketing tactics, seemingly benign, contribute to this rebound effect:

  1. Tactical Pricing and Discount Culture: The prevalence of constant discounts, sales events, and "bargain hunting" is a hallmark of both fast fashion and, increasingly, the second-hand market. While discounts make second-hand clothing more accessible, they can also encourage impulsive buying rather than considered need-based purchases. The psychological allure of a "good deal" can override genuine need, leading to purchases that are ultimately superfluous. This directly mirrors the addictive cycle created by fast fashion's perpetual sales.
  2. Novelty-Driven Merchandising: Just like fast fashion relies on a constant churn of new collections to generate excitement, many second-hand companies also focus on frequent inventory turnover and the "novelty" of new arrivals. This approach encourages consumers to constantly browse and buy, chasing the next unique item. This subtly reinforces the consumerist mindset that constantly seeks novelty, rather than cherishing existing garments or promoting a slower approach to fashion.
  3. Credit for New Purchases: Perhaps the most direct route to the "rebound effect" identified in the study is the practice of offering credit to sellers, not just for further second-hand purchases, but for the acquisition of brand-new items. This directly links the act of "sustainable" selling to the enablement of new consumption, actively contributing to the linear economy rather than disrupting it.

These findings are particularly pertinent to countries in the Global North, where the sheer volume of textile waste necessitates robust second-hand and recycling channels. However, if these channels merely become more efficient at processing waste without genuinely reducing overall consumption, the problem is simply deferred, not solved.

 

The fast fashion graveyard in Chile's Atacama Desert - BBC News

 

Policy Gaps and the Shadow of Waste Colonialism

 

The Turunen and Gossen study implicitly underscores a crucial point that resonates deeply with the issues of "waste colonialism": the market alone cannot solve systemic ethical and environmental problems. The report points to a lack of collaboration within the second-hand sector itself, partly due to the divergent goals of profit-driven businesses versus non-profit charities. This fragmentation hinders comprehensive waste management and the development of truly circular systems.

This internal struggle in the Global North's second-hand market has direct, devastating consequences for the Global South. As our People's Hub Call for Papers on Second Hand Clothing Pipeline highlights, the inability or unwillingness of developed nations to manage their textile waste domestically leads to the massive export of low-quality, unsellable garments. These items flood markets in Ghana, Kenya, Uganda, and other nations, overwhelming local infrastructure and destroying indigenous textile industries.

The "circular economy rebound" identified by Turunen and Gossen in Finnish markets has a chilling parallel in the Global South: if second-hand companies in the North, driven by profitability and consumption-oriented marketing, continue to process vast quantities of fast fashion discards, a significant portion of that discard will inevitably become unsellable, destined for export as "waste colonialism." The more the second-hand market facilitates the churning of low-quality fashion in the North, the more waste arrives at the doors of developing nations, creating environmental catastrophe and stifling local economic growth.

 

Towards a Truly Sustainable Second-Hand Future

 

The paper advocates for critical policy interventions to shift the second-hand market towards genuine sustainability:

  1. Reduced Taxation: Policies such as reduced VAT (Value Added Tax) on reused products could make truly circular business models more profitable without relying on high-volume, potentially excessive, sales.
  2. Quality and Traceability Labels: Implementing clear labeling schemes for reused products, detailing their quality, origin, and any repairs, would build greater consumer trust and promote the value of durability over novelty. This aligns with calls for greater supply chain transparency across the entire fashion sector.
  3. Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR): While not explicitly detailed by Turunen and Gossen, their findings strongly reinforce the urgent need for mandatory EPR schemes for textiles in the Global North. EPR would hold manufacturers financially accountable for the end-of-life of their products, incentivizing them to design for durability and recyclability. This would drastically reduce the flow of low-quality garments into the second-hand market and, by extension, into the Global South.

The "From Preloved to Reloved" study serves as a crucial reality check. It challenges the comfortable assumption that simply buying or selling second-hand is inherently sustainable. For the second-hand clothing industry to truly be a force for good, it must consciously decouple its business model from the consumption imperative and align more deeply with principles of sufficiency and genuine circularity. Without robust policy frameworks and a collective shift in consumer and industry mindset, the second-hand boom risks becoming yet another intricate cog in the machinery of unsustainable consumption, leaving a trail of "waste colonialism" in its wake.

The debate surrounding the international second-hand clothing trade is one of deep, ethical contradiction. While the trade is superficially lauded as a cornerstone of the circular economy in the Global North—diverting tonnes of textiles from landfill—critical analysis and recent reports confirm that its current structure is rapidly devolving into a Second-Hand Clothing Trade as "Waste Colonialism". Two recent major reports sharply capture the complexity of the issue, offering dramatically different perspectives. The core ethical failure emerges when the Global North exports this low-quality excess, thereby destroying the fabric of recipient economies and environments, causing profound economic, cultural, and environmental damage in recipient countries, particularly in Africa.

This situation requires an urgent, focused response to transform the pipeline.

 

Bobby Kolade on waste colonialism and the fashion industry | Nxt Gen Design

 

The Conflicting Narratives: Economy vs. Ecology

 

Two recent major reports sharply capture the complexity of the issue. Offering dramatically different perspectives.

  1. The Pro-Trade Narrative (Oxford Economics): A report commissioned by industry players like Humana People to People and Sympany+ emphasizes the economic benefits. Citing that the trade supports hundreds of thousands of jobs and stimulates billions in GDP across the EU/UK and recipient nations. For example: $76 million contribution to Ghana’s GDP in 2023, supporting 74,400 jobs. This narrative focuses on the trade as a vital component for worldwide circularity and economic inclusion.
  2. The Environmental Warning (WRAP Textiles Market Situation Report 2024): The environmental report from WRAP warns of a "perfect storm" driven by the UK's addiction to cheap, fast fashion. It highlights that the increasing volume and declining quality of donated textiles is strangling the reuse sector. More post-consumer clothing is coming onto the market. However the presence of low-quality items has drastically reduced the price per tonne for used textiles by up to 57.5% in the last decade. Threatening the financial viability of sorting and recycling infrastructure in the UK.

The critical disconnect is that the economic "benefits" cited by one side are directly enabling the environmental catastrophe documented by the other. The export pipeline provides a cheap, convenient way for the Global North to offload a toxic waste problem that it is unable or unwilling to manage domestically.


 

The Global South: Economic Ruin and Environmental Catastrophe

 

The core ethical failure emerges when the Global North exports this low-quality excess. Thereby destroying the fabric of recipient economies and environments.


 

The Solution: Policy and Producer Accountability

 

The pervasive systemic failure necessitates mandatory, phased policy intervention in the Global North. The reports strongly suggest that voluntary agreements are no longer sufficient.

The Second Hand Clothing Export Trade Call for Papers by The People's Hub seeks to put the jigsaw pieces together. Connecting the donation box in the UK to the waste pile in Ghana. To provide the detailed, actionable blueprints needed to achieve this systemic and ethical transformation.

💡 THEME: The Hidden Cost of Donation

📣CALL FOR ACTION-ORIENTED PAPERS

Second Hand Clothing Pipeline: Investigating Waste, Ethics, and Systemic Impact in the Global South

 

The People's Hub invites researchers, investigative journalists, policymakers, fashion industry analysts, and community leaders to submit papers and case studies that disassemble and scrutinize the worldwide second-hand clothing export trade, addressing its role in waste colonialism. However, our focus is not just on critique; rather, we seek in-depth analyses that move beyond mere awareness in order to provide practical, actionable solutions for transforming this critical trade. Through this transformation, we aim to ensure that the trade upholds ethical standards, supports local economies, and minimizes environmental harm in recipient nations. Consequently, accepted papers will be published on The Peoples Hub to inform consumer choices, drive government policy changes, and hold brands and charities accountable.


 

🎯 SCOPE & FOCUS AREAS: Putting the Jigsaw Pieces Together

 

We are looking for papers that investigate the complexity of this trade. Particularly its impact on other nations (e.g., Chile, Ghana, Indonesia, Kenya, Uganda, etc.).

Papers must connect the donation act in the Global North to the resulting economic, environmental, and cultural consequences in the Global South.

  1. The Ethics of Donation and Export:
    • Consumer Deception: Case studies examining the discrepancy between consumer intent (local donation for need) and the reality (bulk export for profit).
    • Policy Gaps: Analysis of regulatory failures or subsidies in exporter nations (e.g., the UK, USA) that incentivize the off-loading of textile waste rather than domestic circular solutions.
    • Requirement: Propose ethical frameworks or certification systems (consistent with the spirit of Note G) for donation organizations.
  2. Impact on Recipient Nations (Economic & Cultural):
    • Economic Collapse: Analysis of how the influx of cheap, high-volume clothing (known as mitumba or similar) destroys local textile manufacturing and tailoring industries.
    • Cultural Disruption: Case studies on how the dominance of Western fast fashion (even second hand) affects cultural dress, traditional textiles, and local fashion identity in recipient countries.
    • Requirement: Identify local initiatives (e.g., upcycling) that are successfully fighting back and propose scaling strategies.
  3. Brands, Waste, and the Supply Chain:
    • Brand Case Studies: Investigations tracing the fate of specific brands' clothes (e.g., Fast Fashion, Luxury, Outdoor Gear) once they enter the export pipeline. Which materials end up as profit, and which end up in landfills or burning piles (e.g., Accra, Ghana)?
    • Transparency and Responsibility: Solutions for compelling major brands to take mandatory financial or physical responsibility for their garments at the end of their first life, rather than relying on the export market as a dumping ground.
  4. Actionable & Circular Alternatives:
    • Closed-Loop Systems: Blueprints for viable, decentralized, and community-led systems for textile circularity in the Global North that prevent clothing from needing to be exported.
    • Fair Trade Second-Hand: Models for restructuring the second hand clothing trade to ensure fair prices. Transparent profit-sharing with recipient country partners, and quality control that prevents unusable clothes from being shipped.

 

Dead White Man's Clothes - Atmos | Part 1: A Closet Full of Clothes


 

✍️ SUBMISSION GUIDELINES

 

We welcome two types of submissions: Investigative Papers and Action Blueprints. All submissions must be highly evidence-based and written to inform and compel action from consumers, corporations, and governments.

Submission Type Length Focus Key Requirement
Investigative Paper 4,000–6,000 words Detailed, original research or reporting tracing the pipeline, identifying key actors, and analyzing environmental/social impact. Must include a "Systemic Recommendations for Policy Change" section.
Action Blueprint 2,000–3,500 words A concise framework for a new ethical, technological, or policy solution, focusing on immediate implementability. Must include a "Stakeholder Implementation Checklist & Resource Guide."

 

Required Sections for ALL Submissions:

 

  1. Title, Author(s), & Affiliation
  2. Executive Summary (250 words): A concise summary of the issue uncovered and the core action steps proposed.
  3. The Donation-Export Connection: Clear definition of the pipeline segment being investigated and its ethical conflict.
  4. Case Study Evidence: Detailed evidence (data, interviews, photographic proof) focusing on specific brands, markets, or waste sites.
  5. Impact Analysis: Clear explanation of the economic, cultural, and environmental consequences in the recipient nation.
  6. Actionable Plan / Policy Blueprint: The most critical section. This must provide step-by-step, transferable instructions or policy recommendations for systemic change.
  7. References: Use a consistent citation style (e.g., APA, Chicago).

 

📅 KEY DATES (Tentative)

 

Action Date
Submission Deadline January 31, 2026
Notification of Acceptance March 15, 2026
Final Paper Submission April 30, 2026
Publication on thepeopleshub.org Starting May 2026

 

📢 THE HUB'S COMMITMENT: PUBLICATION AND ACTION

 

Accepted papers will be utilized to drive tangible change:

 

Submission Procedure

 

All papers must be submitted electronically as a single Word or PDF document to: contact@thepeopleshub.org

The journey toward a sustainable lifestyle begins not with grand policy changes, but with the small, powerful decisions we make every day—specifically, every time we shop. In a complex marketplace full of vague labels, hidden ingredients, and conflicting information, being a "conscious consumer" requires more than good intentions; it requires a versatile, well-stocked toolkit of knowledge and vigilance.

At The People’s Hub, we believe that understanding the interconnectedness of our personal health, the products we use, and Earth is the foundation of genuine sustainability. This comprehensive toolkit provides the necessary perspective and strategies to help you master the key pillars of conscious consumption: choosing healthier, toxic-free products and adopting truly sustainable practices.


 

Tool 1: The Ingredient Decoder 🔍 — Mastering Healthier Choices

 

Choosing better products starts by learning to interpret the marketing language and interrogate what we put in and on our bodies.

 

Tool 2: The Green Chemistry Checklist 🧪 — Adopting Toxic-Free Options

 

Toxic-free living extends far beyond the pantry. The products we use to clean our homes and care for our skin often contain hidden chemicals that can compromise both personal health and environmental quality.

 

Tool 3: The Accountability Compass 🧭 — Conscious Shopping and Sustainable Practices

 

Once you prioritize health and non-toxic ingredients, the next layer of consciousness addresses the product's entire lifecycle and supply chain. This is where sustainable practices come into play.

It is in this area of external accountability that the biggest challenge lies. As consumer demand for ethical products grows, so too does the industry's attempt to capitalize on it, regardless of genuine commitment. Companies often use vague claims, misleading imagery, and carefully chosen language to give the false impression of environmental or social responsibility—a practice known as greenwashing.

Learning to discern authentic sustainability from deceptive marketing is perhaps the most important skill in your toolkit. To ensure your purchasing power is truly driving positive change, we encourage you to read our guide on 'greenwashing'.

 

7 FREE ways you can become a more conscious consumer

 

Tool 4: The Advocacy Amplifier 📢 — Community and Systemic Change

 

True conscious consumption is not just about making better personal purchases; it's about making a better world for everyone. Including those with limited resources, like people who are homeless. The final, most powerful tool in your kit is the realization that individual actions must lead to collective impact.

By combining personal health consciousness with rigorous attention to transparency, you cease to be merely a consumer and become a powerful force for systemic transformation. Every purchase, every question, and every conversation is a vote for the world you want to live in, a world that is healthier, more ethical, and truly sustainable for every member of the Earth community.

Historians face a sobering lesson. Digital memory is a myth. The eternal, searchable record proved false. It dissolved into broken links and purged databases. Algorithmic censorship now dominates this landscape. The infinite web was hailed as history’s archive. It is now the most fragile, manipulated record. The past is not just forgotten. People actively scrub it away. This leaves an unnerving void where facts once stood. Error 404 messages delete vital policy documents. This acts as a digital library burning.

Save Furnitre, Save the Past

Richard Kelly’s masterpiece offered a paradigm shift. His piece, 'Save Furniture, Save the Past,' was brilliant and necessary. Kelly conceived the Dead Sea Stool. This humble, hand-built furniture holds 16 secret names. Spindles bear the names of modern political figures. This profound act creates a counter-archive. It transforms a common object into a vessel of dissent. The stool creates a physical, non-negotiable footnote for future historians. It bypasses every digital firewall and filter. The stool defeats institutional efforts to sanitize the record. This commitment rescues truth from digital decay. We define this cultural resistance as: Encoding History in Fiber and Folk Art.

This philosophy dictates a truth. The most resilient record is easily overlooked. Its destruction requires physical force. The Dead Sea Stool’s power lies in its banality. It is merely a piece of domestic furniture. We must expand this physical archiving beyond woodworking. We need fields allowing for denser, narrative storage. The next essential frontier involves the domestic arts. We expand this philosophy from the carpenter’s workshop. This comprehensive approach is Richard Kelly, Encoding History in Fiber and Folk Art. It extends the method to textile crafts. Specifically, it involves quilts and tapestries.

Wood and hidden compartments encode names. Fiber and pattern encode entire historical narratives. We transform the traditional quilt. It becomes a robust, generation-spanning ledger. We create a permanent, beautiful memory cache. This unassuming cache holds the truth. This truth would otherwise die in the pervasive digital silence.


 

The Tyranny of the Unbroken Link

 

We therefore urgently need this physical turn. We witness documents systematically disappear in real-time. Official health protocols simply vanished. Moreover, scientific declarations were suddenly erased. Embarrassing links now resolve to nothing. Consequently, an institution's hand curates the official record. Time does not select what remains. This digital erasure serves two functions. First, it delegitimizes the inconvenient past. Removing source material quickly forces speculation. Facts easily become a "conspiracy theory." People cannot argue against a non-existent document. Second, it controls future history. Future historians will access a clean, sanitized narrative. This archive effectively deletes policy contradictions and disastrous outcomes.

Against this fragility of the digital realm, textile archives offer four crucial advantages:

  1. Durability: Quilts made centuries ago are still with us. Their materials—cotton, wool, silk—are robust, surviving fires, floods, and the passage of time far better than fragile electronic components or volatile web servers.
  2. Distributability and Replication: A piece of furniture is singular and hard to move; a quilt pattern can be taught, duplicated, and spread across continents, creating a decentralized and unassailable archive network.
  3. Domestic Camouflage: A quilt or tapestry is an object of warmth, art, and comfort. It is not perceived as a subversive text, making it a perfect Trojan Horse of history capable of hiding in plain sight for generations.
  4. Tangibility: It requires no technology—no power, no software, no specific device—to read. It is accessible by human hands and eyes alone, a future-proof method of information retrieval.

 

The Cipher of Fiber: Encoding Complex Data

 

The true power of the textile archive lies in its capacity for dense, multi-layered encoding. Quilts and tapestries are inherently systems of pattern, color, and repetition, allowing the creator to embed information at several different depths, guaranteeing that even if the surface code is compromised, the deeper message remains.

 

1. The Language of Pattern Alteration

 

Traditional quilt patterns—such as the "Log Cabin," the "Broken Dishes," or the "Nine Patch"—serve as the foundation for the cipher. The archivist does not invent a new, suspicious pattern, but subtly alters a recognizable one.

 

2. The Granularity of Stitch Count

 

This method offers the potential for encoding numerical or date-based data with high precision. Instead of weaving a message into a border using a Morse code of colors, the archivist employs the Fibonacci sequence, prime numbers, or specific historical dates within the visible stitches.

 

3. The Cipher of Color and Material

 

Color assignment allows for the encoding of abstract concepts, organizational affiliations, or ideological positions, creating a symbolic lexicon that can be read only by those initiated into the system.

Color Symbolic Encoding (Example) Data Type
Deep Indigo Institutional Authority / Government Edict Subject
Bright Yellow Unforeseen Consequences / Adverse Event Consequence
Faded Grey Censorship / Historical Erasure Action
Unbleached Linen The Original, Untainted Fact / Truth Source

The choice of fabric material can also be an intentional part of the archive. A small, hidden square of raw, unprocessed wool (a historically valuable commodity) could represent an economic crisis, while a square of synthetic polyester (a modern innovation) could symbolize a technological failure or breakthrough.

Richard Kelly, Encoding History in Fiber and Folk Art
Richard Kelly, Encoding History in Fiber and Folk Art

 

4. The Deep Archive: The Secret Backing

 

The most secure layer of the textile archive is the reverse side—the backing fabric that rests unseen against the wall or bed. This space is reserved for the meta-data and the key to the cipher.

Here, using tiny, tightly packed embroidery, the archivist can create a textual inscription, invisible unless the quilt is intentionally turned over and closely examined. This could include:

The secret backing is the equivalent of the Dead Sea Stool's concealed interior, designed to survive only for those future archivists who are diligent enough to look beyond the surface.


 

Historical Provenance and the Persistence of Fiber

 

We embrace the quilt as an archive. Doing this acknowledges the subversive history of domestic crafts. Textiles are not trivial. Instead, they have always stored coded information. They provide political commentary. This was especially true for voices excluded from formal communication.

For example, consider the Underground Railroad Quilts legend. Some historians claim the quilts conveyed coded messages. A "Monkey Wrench" pattern signaled gathering tools. A "Wagon Wheel" pattern indicated an escape route. Therefore, the method's plausibility shows the medium's inherent potential. An illiterate or closely watched person could read a quilt block change. A written document would have invited seizure or betrayal.

Likewise, various cultures commissioned elaborate tapestries. They served not just aesthetic pleasure. Rather, they preserved politically charged histories. These histories contradicted the ruling narrative. Women often executed the needlework. Authorities dismissed these women as politically irrelevant. Consequently, their work became the true, hidden record. People passed it down as "women's work." Meanwhile, officials revised and rewrote histories.

This use establishes powerful provenance for the modern archivist. We create a Historical Quilt. We join an ancient, decentralized tradition. This is cultural resistance. Crucially, it weaponizes everyday banality. It moves against the vast machinery of the State. This is the ultimate intellectual defiance. The truth lies close enough to sleep under. Yet, no surveillance or algorithm can detect it.


 

A Call for a New Guild of Archivists

 

The creation of a physical archive, whether a Dead Sea Stool or a Historical Quilt, is not a call to withdraw from the digital world, but to acknowledge its fundamental limitations. It is an investment in generations, not seconds.

We issue a call to all craftsmen, artists, and creators who understand the value of permanence: join the Guild of the Unwritten Archive.

This guild's mandate is simple: to transform objects of utility and beauty into redundant data-storage systems.

This is the ultimate long-game against censorship. The architects of digital purges rely on the speed and transience of the internet, assuming that any counter-narrative will simply fade away as the servers crash and the links decay. They do not account for the silent, patient persistence of thread and timber.

The Historical Quilt is an act of profound optimism. It is a faith in the future, a belief that one hundred years from now, a grandchild will pull an old, heavy quilt from a cedar chest, turn it over to inspect a small tear, and discover an intentionally placed knot, leading them to a series of carefully counted stitches, which in turn unlocks the true, unedited, inconvenient history of their forebears. The message will not be delivered via a glowing screen or a brittle paper file, but by the warmth and weight of a domestic artifact—a truth you can literally hold in your hands.

The furniture has been saved; now, let us begin the weaving.

Ada's Army is more than just a volunteer initiative; it is a continuation of a long and powerful legacy of women (especially from Scotland) who have tirelessly fought for a more just world. We believe that by celebrating and re-creating their stories, we can ignite a new generation of activists who understand that the struggle for women’s rights is built on the bravery of those who came before us.

The Women Who Changed the Gender Ruling

This is a call to artists, poets, writers, and digital creators to help us bring these incredible lives to life. We want to honor their memory and amplify their message by making their history accessible, inspiring, and unforgettable. Your contribution will transform historical records into living narratives—through cartoons, poetry, comics, images, and more—that resonate with people today.

The Unsung Heroes of the Scottish Suffrage Movement

While the names of Emmeline Pankhurst and Millicent Garrett Fawcett are widely known, the Scottish suffragettes who risked everything for the vote are often overlooked. The movement in Scotland was a vibrant and complex tapestry of both peaceful and militant activism, with women from all walks of life demonstrating remarkable courage and strategic prowess. They fought against a male-dominated political establishment and a deeply ingrained societal resistance to change, often facing hostility from the press and public alike.

The journey was long and arduous. It began with the "suffragists" who, through constitutional means like petitions and public debates, laid the foundational groundwork. However, frustrated by the lack of progress, many turned to the more radical "suffragette" movement, a term coined by the press to deride their militant actions. Yet, for these women, the escalating tactics were a necessary and a bold act of rebellion against an indifferent state.

Dr. Elsie Inglis (1864-1917): The Physician and Humanitarian

Born in India, Dr. Elsie Inglis embodies the spirit of both scientific innovation and political activism. After returning to Scotland, she faced significant barriers to her medical education but persevered, becoming a pioneering doctor and surgeon. Her activism began with her frustration at the poor state of medical care available to women. This led her to a deeper conviction that women needed a voice in government to address such systemic inequalities.

Inglis was not a militant suffragette, but a leading figure in the peaceful movement. She served as the secretary of the Edinburgh National Society for Women's Suffrage and was a tireless advocate for change through reasoned argument and public speaking. Her true legacy, however, came during the First World War. When she offered to set up medical units for the war effort, the British War Office infamously told her to "go home and sit still."

Instead of accepting this dismissal, Inglis took matters into her own hands. She founded the Scottish Women's Hospitals for Foreign Service, an organization staffed and funded entirely by women. This was a direct extension of the suffrage movement, demonstrating women’s competence and patriotism in the face of male-led resistance. From the battlefields of Serbia to Russia, these hospitals provided critical care to wounded soldiers, and Inglis herself was a commanding presence, working in the field and negotiating with military officials. She was awarded the highest Serbian honor for her heroic work. Her life story is a powerful testament to the idea that a woman’s fight for her rights and her dedication to the service of others are one and the same.

Flora Drummond (1878-1949): "The General"

Nicknamed "The General" for her commanding presence and military-style uniform, Flora Drummond was a formidable force in the militant suffragette movement. Born in Manchester but raised on the Isle of Arran, her early life was marked by a personal injustice that fueled her activism: she was denied a job as a postmistress for being one inch too short. This experience of arbitrary discrimination against women resonated deeply with her and solidified her commitment to fighting for equality.

Drummond became a key organizer for the Women's Social and Political Union (WSPU), founded by the Pankhurst family. Her skills as a public speaker were legendary; she could command a crowd and deftly put down hecklers. She was a master of grand, theatrical protests, including once mooring a barge outside the Houses of Parliament to draw attention to a suffrage rally. She was imprisoned nine times for her activism, which included inciting public gatherings and disrupting political events.

When she organized the first major WSPU procession in Edinburgh in 1909, she drew an estimated 10,000 women, with some dressed as famous Scottish historical figures to connect their modern fight with a national legacy of defiance. Her life story is a narrative of unwavering determination and a willingness to use creative, and often risky, tactics to gain a platform and force the political establishment to listen.

Frances Parker (1875-1924): A Militant Force from New Zealand

Born in New Zealand, where women already had the right to vote, Frances Parker was a member of a prominent family and the niece of Lord Kitchener. She left New Zealand for a privileged education at Cambridge, where she became committed to the British suffrage movement. Her background and connections did not shield her from the brutal realities of the campaign.

Parker quickly became a prominent leader in the WSPU's Scottish chapter, known for her dedication to militant acts. She was imprisoned several times for her activism, including for her involvement in a mass window-smashing campaign in London. In prison, she went on hunger strikes and was subjected to the horrific, and often sexually violent, practice of force-feeding. A doctor at Perth Prison attempted to feed her rectally, causing severe bruising. She later wrote about her ordeal, bringing public attention to the inhumane treatment of suffragettes.

Her most infamous action in Scotland was the attempt to burn down Robert Burns's cottage in Alloway in 1914 with fellow suffragette Ethel Moorhead. Though they were caught, the act was a powerful, if controversial, statement. It was not out of hatred for the poet, but a symbolic act of defiance, invoking Burns's famous lines about liberty to justify their radical means.


We are looking for passionate individuals who can help us make these stories and many more—of women like Helen Crawfurd, Maud Edwards, and Ethel Moorhead—come alive for a new generation. By translating their history into modern creative forms, you will be giving voice to the voiceless, honoring the past, and actively shaping a more equitable future.

The Genesis of The Rash rests on a cinematic allegory. Specifically, the film will elevate a figure of modern intellectual dissent. The premise focuses on one scientist. Indeed, he "dared to ask questions when they were most needed." This directly addresses public policy debates of recent years. Moreover, the narrative aims to resonate deeply with audiences. They felt institutional consensus stifled necessary discourse. Therefore, the decision to frame the story as an allegory is deliberate. This form uses characters to represent philosophical meanings.

It positions the film not just as a historical retelling, but as a timeless commentary on the nature of truth, authority, and courage in the face of prevailing orthodoxies. The title itself, The Rash, hints at a hidden, underlying malady, suggesting that the public health crisis was merely the symptom of a deeper, perhaps systemic, societal issue. A rash can be irritating, disruptive, and a physical manifestation of a deeper immune response. The film’s metaphorical rash is likely the outbreak of dissent. The sudden appearance of inconvenient facts, or the intellectual pushback against an accepted narrative. It signals the disruptive presence of a viewpoint that cannot easily be ignored.

 

The Intellectual Cornerstone: Modeling the Figure on Jay Bhattacharya

 

The central figure in the film is modeled on Jay Bhattacharya. A significant detail that immediately grounds the allegory in real-world policy and scientific debate. Dr. Bhattacharya is a respected physician-scientist and health economist at Stanford University. Recently named to a major leadership position at the National Institutes of Health (NIH). His reputation is built not only on his academic credentials but also on his high-profile advocacy for a policy response focused on "focused protection" for vulnerable populations. As articulated in the Great Barrington Declaration.

The Intellectual Foundation is quite rigorous. Dr. Bhattacharya's intellectual work blends health economics and epidemiology. Specifically, he argued broad restrictions cost too much. These costs included educational deficits and mental health crises. Consequently, these effects outweighed public health benefits. This was especially true for people not at extreme risk. Therefore, he urged a nuanced, risk-stratified approach. His perspective demanded skepticism toward one-size mandates. The Brownstone Institute sees this not as mere policy choice. Instead, they view it as an act of intellectual bravery. The film will capture the pressure and isolation he faced. Thus, it explores the moral clarity needed by a professional scientist. This thematic focus makes the intellectual struggle potent commentary.

 

The Creative Engine: Alex Moyers and Walter Kirn

 

The success of such an allegorical project hinges entirely on the creative talents at its helm, and the Brownstone Institute appeal names a powerful duo.

The screenplay is being penned by Walter Kirn, described as a "legendary critic and essayist." Kirn’s body of work, which includes the critically acclaimed novel Up in the Air, demonstrates an established capacity for sharp social observation. A narrative craftsmanship that navigates the complexities of contemporary American life. His involvement suggests that The Rash will possess not only intellectual depth but also the necessary satirical edge. With the human element to succeed as commercial cinema. A critic’s eye for societal absurdities is perfectly suited for crafting a story about a figure whose scientific integrity places him outside the political norm.

Coupled with director Alex Moyers, the project aims to translate the abstract drama of scientific and policy disagreement into a compelling visual medium. The collaboration between a renowned critical writer and a director with a clear vision is intended to ensure the finished film is a high-quality production. Capable of reaching a mass audience. Thereby achieving the desired "enormous commercial success." The Brownstone Institute is banking on the quality of the storytelling to carry its message into the mainstream.

 

The Financial Autonomy: The Brownstone Institute’s Fiscal Sponsorship

 

Perhaps the most significant aspect of this appeal is the role of the Brownstone Institute itself. Led by founder and president Jeffrey Tucker, the organization’s primary mission is to advance ideas that uphold individual liberty and robust public discourse. The Institute has emerged as a prominent voice advocating for economic and social openness, particularly in response to governmental overreach.

The Genesis of The Rash highlights the Institute's clear intent. Indeed, they state the funding must bypass "the usual sources." Consequently, they reject compromise from corporate or studio interests. This approach ensures the film's message remains powerful and uncensored. Studios often dilute controversial or sensitive topics. Therefore, the Institute seeks capital through robust crowdsourcing efforts. Ultimately, this funding model presents a vital challenge. It proves alternative viewpoints secure successful financing. Crucially, dedicated donors alone bring these projects to fruition. Thus, this fundraising drive tests independent cultural production. It operates entirely outside established patronage networks.

Jeffrey Tucker’s involvement, including his availability for meetings with potential high-level donors and the promotion of his new book, underscores his dedication to integrating intellectual commentary with tangible cultural output. His book, framed as a "blueprint for psychological resistance disguised as cultural commentary," serves as a literary companion piece to the film’s mission. Emphasizing the necessity of intellectual self-reliance.

 

The Relevance of Von Mises Today | Jeffrey A. Tucker

 

Conclusion: Sustaining a Movement and a Message

 

The appeal is skillfully woven into the context of the organization's wider efforts, specifically the approaching annual gala in Salt Lake City, The Great Transition Event in USA where Dr. Jay Bhattacharya is slated to appear as a guest. The gala acts as a physical gathering point for the community that supports the Brownstone Institute. Providing a nexus where donors, intellectuals, and filmmakers can converge to celebrate and sustain their movement.

Ultimately, the Brownstone Institute is not simply asking for donations to produce a film; it is requesting support for a multi-pronged strategy to reshape the cultural conversation. By financing The Rash, sponsoring intellectual events, and maintaining its publishing arm, the Institute seeks to solidify its capacity to "sustain and expand the work we do." This entire effort represents a profound commitment to using all available tools. From economics and science to cinematic art. To champion the cause of open inquiry and independent thought.

When in the Course of human events, it becomes necessary for one people to dissolve the political bands which have connected them with another, and to assume among the powers of the earth, the separate and equal station to which the Laws of Nature and of Nature's God entitle them, a decent respect to the opinions of mankind requires that they should declare the causes which impel them to the separation.
GLOBAL GATHERINGSSOCIAL IMPACTONLINE FUNDRAISINGCONTACT

Subscribe

* indicates required
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram